Whose fault is it?

In small business, we tend to give out titles with aplomb. You can be a manager. You’re a director. You are a vice president. When there are few levels to differentiate between, it seems meaningless to attach a lot of weight to a title.

Your receivables clerk comes to you and says “I think I could get more respect when I collect if I was the Accounting Manager.” You agree. What harm is int it?

After a couple of years he or she has a review. “I’ve been the Accounting Manager for three years. I feel like I’m going nowhere. I would like to be promoted to Controller.” What’s the difference? Should you dole out the Controller title?

So how do you discern the difference between a supervisor and a real manager? Each directs the work of other people. Both have responsibilities. Is it just a matter of degree? I know construction supervisors who oversee millions of dollars and scores of employees and subcontractors. I know managers in small companies with just a couple of direct reports, yet they are as talented in managing as anyone. What is the difference?

Here’s a quick measure. When something goes wrong, whose fault is it?

The supervisor says “It’s their fault. They didn’t do what I told them to do.”
The manager says “It’s my fault. They didn’t do what I told them to do.”

The supervisor sees his job as telling people what they should do. The manager knows that his job is getting them to do it.

This entry was posted in Incentives, Leadership, Managing Employees and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *